AL East Futures: Yankees The Favorite After Busy Offseason

Quinn Allen
By: Quinn Allen
10 Feb 25
MLB
MLB

The 2025 MLB season is right around the corner after a productive winter where numerous ball club strengthened their rosters. One of the best divisions in baseball each and every year is the American League East and that should once again be the case.

The New York Yankees are the frontrunner, but the Baltimore Orioles and Boston Red Sox should also be in the mix for the AL East crown. Below, we’ll analyze the field and dive into what moves some of these teams made in the last few months.

Highlights

  • The Yankees are the favorite in the AL East futures
  • The Orioles and Red Sox are behind them
  • We’ll preview the division below

Yankees 

The Bronx Bombers were definitely gutted when Juan Soto decided to leave the organization in free agency and sign a 15-year, $765 million deal with the crosstown rival New York Mets. That didn’t start the Yankees’ offseason in the best manner, but they’ve made up for it. Last season’s World Series finalists traded for Cody Bellinger to slot into the heart of their lineup and he should hit lots of homers with the short porch in right field.  

NY also brought in All-Star closer Devin Williams in a trade with the Milwaukee Brewers, sending Nestor Cortes the other way. Perhaps the most notable move however was the signing of lefty Max Fried, who will be a stud at the top of the rotation with Gerrit Cole. Paul Goldschmidt also inked a one-year contract. Losing Soto wasn’t ideal, but the Yankees’ front office did a solid job still improving. They have +105 odds to repeat as AL East winners at Sports Interaction

Orioles 

Will the Orioles finally live up to expectations? This ball club has been legit over the last two seasons and have been deemed a World Series contender. Yet, they’ve lost in the Wild Card Series in back-to-back years. Thankfully, the core of Adley Rutschman, Gunnar Henderson, Jackson Holliday, and others remain young. Plus, Baltimore has a plethora of prospects not far off the big leagues, too. The O’s added a few solid pieces this offseason to boot. Tyler O’Neill will join their outfield after spending last season with the Boston Red Sox, clubbing 31 homers. He should be an immediate replacement from a power standpoint for Anthony Santander.  

On the mound, Baltimore added proven veteran Charlie Morton, who should give them experience and obviously production despite his age. The  Orioles finished just three games behind the Yankees in 2024 and have the second-best AL East odds at MLB betting sites

Red Sox 

Boston has been active in free agency, but their fans still want more. While trading for Garrett Crochet and signing Walker Buehler improve their rotation, the Red Sox could still use more offense. Buzz around a Nolan Arenado trade continues to circulate, while Alex Bregman remains a free agent as well, but he’d have to play second base. The loss of O’Neill is significant for Boston considering the power output he brought to the table. Another bat is certainly needed, while more bullpen arms wouldn’t hurt, either.

Rays, Blue Jays won’t contend 

Both the Tampa Bay Rays and Toronto Blue Jays didn’t do much this offseason and it will hurt their chances in a competitive AL East. The Rays will have more or less the same roster as ‘24 but stud left-hander Shane McClanahan will return from Tommy John. That will provide them with a massive boost at the top of the rotation.

As for the Jays, they swung and missed on Juan Soto and Pete Alonso. However, Anthony Santander signed with the team and brings huge power to their lineup. Also, Max Scherzer is set to become a Blue Jay, joining an already talented rotation. But, it’s hard to imagine Toronto finishing anywhere above third in the AL East. This core hasn’t been able to get the job done and be consistent throughout a 162-game season.

Quinn Allen is a seasoned sports journalist from Vancouver, Canada. Quinn is a full-time senior editor for ClutchPoints where he specializes in baseball, soccer, basketball, and football. Quinn has been working in the industry for five years and brings a unique outlook to sports journalism, having played high-level soccer and baseball growing up. Quinn resides in Kelowna, Canada, and enjoys playing soccer and going to the gym.